Just saw this mentioned. It’s interesting how an idea that, years ago, was just a method of harnessing existing technology, can re-appear as something funky and brand new. It joins those other technologies that aim to get data into our devices via cost-free, non-contact interfaces, such as QR Codes.
What is Chirp?
A Chirp™ is a sonic barcode. With Chirp technology, data and content can be encoded into a unique audio stream. Any device with a speaker can transmit a chirp and most devices with a microphone can decode them.
People of a certain age will be familiar with the use of audio cassettes as storage for their microcomputer programs back in the 1980s – I think I used reel-to-reel for a time.
I also remember, round about 1980, sending a computer program over the phone to a friend’s house by holding the phone close to the speaker and picking the sound up at the other end with a microphone. As I recall, our version wasn’t really very reliable or practical, but I think we did succeed in sending a short program. Obviously we were inspired by the audio coupler modems that we might have seen in films and documentaries.
SMPTE and MIDI timecodes can be recorded as audio signals on analogue tape and can survive multiple transfers and, I dare say, would be robust enough to work over a speaker-microphone link.
In the 1990s we were all familiar with ‘the sound of data’ when we used dial-up modems.
Over the years we have also had DTMF dialling, audio watermarking, Shazam, Siri, Alexa etc. and phone-based automated systems using speech recognition, all of which have to deal with extracting ‘data’ from noisy audio. You would think that the new audio barcodes should be pretty simple to make work reliably.
There’s a brilliant film from the 1950s called The Man in the White Suit. It’s a satire on capitalism, the power of the unions, and the story of how the two sides find themselves working together to oppose a new invention that threatens to make several industries redundant.
I wonder if there’s a tenuous resemblance between the film’s new wonder-fabric and the invention of digital audio? I hesitate to say that it’s exactly the same, because someone will point out that in the end, the wonder-fabric isn’t all it seems and falls apart, but I think they do have these similarities:
- The new invention is, for all practical purposes, ‘perfect’, and is immediately superior to everything that has gone before.
- It is cheap – very cheap – and can be mass-produced in large quantities.
- It has the properties of infinite lifespan, zero maintenance and non-obsolescence
- It threatens the profits not only of the industry that invented it, but other related industries.
In the film it all turns a bit dark, with mobs on the streets and violence imminent. Only the invention’s catastrophic failure saves the day.
In the smaller worlds of audio and music, things are a little different. Digital audio shows no signs of failing, and it has taken quite a few years for someone to finally come up with a comprehensive, feasible strategy for monopolising the invention while also shutting the Pandora’s box that was opened when it was initially released without restrictions.
The new strategy is this:
- Spread rumours that the original invention was flawed
- Re-package the invention as something brand new, with a vagueness that allows people to believe whatever they want about it
- Deviate from the rigid mathematical conditions of the original invention, opening up possibilities for future innovations in filtering and “de-blurring”. The audiophile imagination is a potent force, so this may not be the last time you can persuade them to re-purchase their record collections, after all.
- Offer to protect the other, affected industries – for a fee
- Appear to maintain compatibility with the original invention – for now – while substituting a more inconvenient version with inferior quality for unlicensed users
- Through positive enticements, nudge users into voluntarily phasing out the original invention over several years.
- Introduce stronger protection once the window has been closed.
It’s a very clever strategy, I think. Point (2) is the master stroke.